Actress Julianne Moore won an Oscar for her starring role in the drama “Still Alice” at the 87th Academy Awards last night, but did the movie accurately depict early-onset dementia? Actor Eddie Redmayne also received one of the coveted gold statues, but was his portrayal of Stephen Hawking’s neurological disorder scientifically defensible in the biopic “The Theory of Everything”?
In fact, Spiers awarded both films a “Golden Brain Award” – her version of the Academy Awards – on her website, NeuroPsyFi.com, which critiques the way movies depict brain disorders. Other movies this year that portrayed brain disorders or special brain abilities included “Lucy” with Scarlett Johansson (cognitive enhancement), “The Imitation Game” with Benedict Cumberbatch (Asperger’s syndrome) and “St. Vincent” with Bill Murray (stroke).
The goal of Spiers’ site, which is funded by a grant from the Association for Psychological Science’s Fund for Teaching and Public Understanding of Psychological Science, is to educate consumers, teachers and filmmakers about the brain science behind the movies. Through descriptions and peer-reviewed critiques by neuropsychologists, teachers and psychology students, the site dispels common “neuromyths” perpetuated by Hollywood.
From the action movie “The Bourne Identity” to the cartoon “Finding Nemo, ” countless major motion pictures have been inspired by brain disorders.
“People generally find psychological disorders fascinating, ” said Spiers. “Neuropsychological disorders, as a subset, are also captivating because we’re interested in how our minds work and what can happen if something goes wrong. We love stories and we’re interested to find out how people will cope, and hopefully, prevail.
Even in a seemingly hopeless situation, as in the case of ‘Still Alice, ’ when Moore’s character knows she will ultimately ‘lose herself’ to Alzheimer’s disease, we are looking for how to carry on and derive meaning from life when all memory of self is gone. Alternately, in the case of ‘The Theory of Everything’ we can also take a lesson from the incredible way that Stephen Hawking has prevailed and triumphed despite dealing with a devastating disease.”
Spiers believes that, while movies that accurately portray neurological disorders can help viewers empathize with those with the condition, those that are inaccurate can do more harm than good by perpetuating stereotypes.
“The movie was based on the true story of Alan Turing, but falls back on the trope of the ‘math genius with Asperger’s syndrome, ’” said Spiers. “However, there is much debate about whether Turing actually was on the autism spectrum.
Some of the symptoms in the film seemed to me to be ‘pasted on’ rather than truly integrated into his character – the film seems to be more concerned with artistic license than with accuracy.”
As far as which movies portray brain science most accurately, Spiers cites the psychological thriller “Memento” (2000) as a prime example.
“[‘Memento’ director] Christopher Nolan’s brother got the idea from his general psychology class, ” Spiers said. “The style of ‘Memento’ takes the audience into the head of a person with severe anterograde amnesia and so attempts to mimic the feeling of the disorder.”
A new initiative of Spiers’, her recently launched Writer’s Brain Lab Blog, aims to help writers of fiction and other film and TV industry professionals to portray brain science more accurately. While Spiers does believe that most writers are genuinely interested in trying to get the brain science correct, she claims that some sources are more reliable than others.
“Trolling the web is not the best way to be sure that one is developing a believable character or correctly interpreting how brain imaging should be used, ” said Spiers. “Writers really need expert advice from psychologists. Our Writer’s Brain Lab Blog hopes to provide that forum.”
NeuroPsyFi.com also offers learning resources, including materials to help teachers link real psychological science to popular movies and TV shows.
Spiers started NeuroPsyFi.com in early 2013, inspired by the experience of using movie clips to illustrate points in her psychology courses.
“The website was an extension of the idea that people are curious about finding out what is accurate in fiction, ” Spiers said. “When people watch a movie, they often want to know if memory actually works the way it is portrayed, or if a person with a neurological disorder like traumatic brain injury, would actually behave as the movie character acts. Our mission is to educate consumers and to encourage them to be curious about the portrayals of those with neurological disorders in movies, as well as the assertions about the brain.”
an equation whose degree is 1 is known as where to study engineering in south africa? why marketing matters how many favourites win at cheltenham 2022? which overcome barriers? where object to array? what degree is a pitching wedge? whose skills? where to list skills on resume? when meaning in urdu how much skills are there where question activities? which math should i take in college? why developer option is hidden on firestick which means synonym? who leads the nfl in interceptions? which important detail about bass algorithm who invented where to watch skills challenge how much meaning in telugu how much recruitment agencies charge in india where to plot cumulative frequency graphs? how often does favorite win in nba how much interview job? which industries are examples of natural monopolies? which facility heist pays the most who object pronoun? where does leadership come from how many research tasks pokemon arceus what do most treadmills measure distance in how often to calibrate? why research turabian? check when theory test expires? how many challenge seasons how far question word what maintenance does a tesla need how often do creditors object to discharge whose career did goldberg end? why intelligence fails where does engineers work? where to import jdm cars what object is 7 inches how often does instagram algorithm update how many answers are on the permit test how many research levels in pokemon snap? where to research crypto how challenge coins are made? how theory research and practice are interrelated which interview question is legally valid how theory helps the understanding of development? who object of the verb? whose role is important for development work? how many machine learning algorithms are there why influence is important in leadership who workshop report which method of research is best? why classification is better than regression how much degree in mumbai how internet is made? how many examples sentences how questions for kids where meaning in spanish how many leadership positions should i have? how many leadership positions should i have for college where to find intelligence folder tarkov? where to overcome anger how often questions options how many workshops in fallout 4? how overcome anxiety which challenge is unique to environmental science? how many skills for cna test when industry 5 0 start? how much is algorithm worth? whose meaning in english? what is common classification what blogger means? where to rent workshop space? how much users can use netflix? where is challenge road in mario party? how leadership actually works when interview goes over time? where is dean wilson from create and craft which users will be members of group1? how often should you change your oil how many maintenance planners do i need? when degree colleges start in telangana 2022 when leadership is hard? how often can we do scaling where to find leader sierra? what is vacancies? where to find degree apprenticeships how much architect to design house? where to watch leadership debate how industrial refrigeration systems work where to stream career opportunities when developer rejects the bug? what leaders do why leaders don't learn from success? summary where the wild things are how often should an algorithm be updated how much subject in bca? how many architectural shingles in a bundle how many architect in the world? whose operations influence the betterment of the countries whose objective is the protection of local industries what is an everyday leader? where to plot independent and dependent variables? where to classify bad debt expense how much subject you need to be a soldier how often work out to lose weight how far example sentences with answers? where is the workshop in sanctuary fallout 4 how many algorithms mahout support for clustering who create electricity? how architect works? how much important is money in life where to find classified ads? how facility management works? how much users can use netflix? how influence music? why intelligence is not enough? how many leaders are in seventeen? when answers aren't enough karaoke skills when working? how much activity is 4 mets? how many industries are in the stock market? facetheory how much research experience for grad school how to manage maintenance where is ups regional origin facility how long should a workshop be? how many degree celsius today? why recruiter ask for ssn? how is correctional facility when is workshop shaco available? why math is hard why engineering college essay? where can i get a copy of my degree? how developer works on hair? subject where x is found for short what degree is a fever which algorithm is not greedy algorithm how engineering firms practise sustainability how many theory of play are there where to classify business expenses when subject to? what challenge have you overcome how many activities for a 4 year old what industrial revolution are we in 2022? why interview with hr where math comes from who generation lyrics how often grading? is it a opportunity or an opportunity? how industrial revolution started? can work or can works? blog meaning where to see developer options in android who recruiting process? why architects are poor where is leaders debate tonight? how much marketing budget should be? how long grow avocado from seed? when leaders lead how much maintenance is a hot tub where architect sleep? how working from home affects mental health what object is 6mm? why working from home will stick how many facilities does hca have what working from home is like how many maintenance staff do i need what workshop to buy bannerlord where to start career pga 2k21? who uses afterpay whose en ingles why algorithm and flowchart are used in programming? whom answer where to find engineering jobs who pays recruiter fees? where is hedocell located? which examples are of biotechnology how far example sentences with answers? how often does jerry's workshop open? how much important is physical intimacy in a relationship? what algorithm does arrays sort use why developer use linux how often questions grammar? whom plural examples how much transfer paypal how many intelligence agencies does america have? when machine gun invented? where to add workshop certificate in linkedin why important to drink fluids when sick? how often do workshops get attacked? which challenge was diems last? why user stories where to grow asparagus? who developed the atomic bomb whose role or who's role which developer to use with toner? how many architect in the world? when recruiter asks about salary expectations when meaning in urdu how engineering firms practise sustainability? why diagrams in uml? where i am from examples who provides internet in my address who is the owner of internet in world which subject should i study first? when interview ask your weakness? who industrial application where research questions how many classification of masonry tools are there? which summary is the best fit for this passage? workshop where metals are melted or refined where is groove theory from? what means lol? where to job shadow how far plant tomatoes apart? powershell where object from variable? subject where x is found? how much improve vo2 max when machine learning goes off the rails? where is ups regional origin facility how many developers work on minecraft? where to publish leadership articles how long transfer between banks what leadership means? where object from array? who architect burj khalifa? how industries cause pollution? how much architect salary? where to import cars from japan? how challenge coins work? how often an activity is performed each week how many internet mbps do i need what engineering is the easiest? where to improve kindness persona 5? where do degrees come from? how much grow light do succulents need how many industries should i invest in? how much meaning in telugu? who funds opportunity wisconsin? where did manek transfer from where does classification mean? how many activities on eras when algorithms go wrong? how much leader should i use on braid who and whom questions how long interview last where meaning and example how much blogger earn in youtube where does pie come from math? when meaning in punjabi? when answers aren't enough how many math questions are on the act? why summary is the condensed section of research where are workshop mods stored? how architect dress? summary where the mind is without fear? why is persistence important in leadership? how workshop is conducted who internet betting how often is continuously? what questions are on the permit test how machine learning algorithms work what machine cuts acrylic
